core/agent+cli: persist user immediately; /retry reuses DB turn

Keep incomplete user messages in memory/DB; roll back only
assistant/tool on failure. /retry and resume of orphan-user sessions
re-run without duplicating the user message.

CLAUDE.md

@@ -55,7 +55,7 @@ Async SQLAlchemy + aiosqlite. `MemoryStore`: schema init (+ lightweight SQLite `
 - **`ChatClient`** Protocol for `chat_completions`.
 - **`@tool` / `ToolRegistry`**: decorator infers JSON Schema from type hints; execute tools by name.
 - **`run_chat_loop`**: multi-round tool loop; default **streaming** text deltas + stream tool-call merge; parallel tools; tool-result char budget; soft context compact on request (**API-calibrated** after first usage when available); cooperative cancel points; optional `on_limit`.
-- **`ChatAgent`**: optional `MemoryStore` (persist on success only); `stream`; system prompt; `pending_retry_text` + `retry()`.
+- **`ChatAgent`**: optional `MemoryStore` (user message persisted immediately; assistant/tools on success); `stream`; system prompt; `pending_retry_text` + `retry()` for incomplete turns (including orphan user after resume).
 - **`/compact`**: soft-compact tool dumps → model summary (no tools) → **new** session seeded with summary message.
 - Events: text_delta, assistant_message, tool_call/result, max_rounds, **error** (`retryable`/`source`), **cancelled** (`reason`), **usage** (`TokenUsage`).
 - Usage: API `usage` from completions (stream with `include_usage`); **char≈token fallback** (~4 chars/token) when omitted; **context size** = last request ``prompt_tokens`` (API preferred); `last_turn_usage` / `session_usage` are **billed sums** (tool rounds re-send history); CLI end-of-turn + `/status`.
@@ -81,7 +81,7 @@ Click app + readline REPL. Entry: `plyngent` / `python -m plyngent`.
 - **`plyngent chat`**: provider/model selection (flags or interactive), SQLite sessions via config `[database]` (file DB under user data if unset/`:memory:`), sessions bound to workspace dir; resumes **most recently updated** session for cwd/`--workspace` by default (`--new` / `--session`).
 - Slash: `/history`, `/sessions` (newest first), `/resume [id]`, `/compact`, `/status` (incl. context char estimate), `/rounds`, `/retry`, …
 - Explicit `/resume` or `--session` from another workspace prompts: **keep** session path, **update** binding to current, or **abort**.
-- Failed/cancelled turns: not written to DB; Ctrl+C cancels the in-flight turn task; **TTY confirms** (max-rounds / destructive tools) run off-loop via `asyncio.to_thread` + pause cancel so prompts do not abort the turn; auto-retry 10s/20s/30s; `/retry` manual.
+- Failed/cancelled turns: user message kept in DB; partial assistant/tool rolled back; Ctrl+C cancels in-flight turn; **TTY confirms** off-loop; auto-retry 10s/20s/30s then `/retry` (no duplicate user message).
 - **`plyngent providers`**: list config providers.
 - **`plyngent config path|edit`**: print or open config in `$EDITOR` (`shlex`-split, e.g. `codium --wait`).
 - If no providers and `$EDITOR` is set, chat/providers prompt to edit config then reload.

src/plyngent/agent/chat.py

@@ -87,6 +87,7 @@ class ChatAgent:
         self.last_request_usage = TokenUsage()
         self.last_turn_rounds = 0
         self._ensure_system_prompt()
+        self._sync_pending_from_orphan_user()
 
     @property
     def context_tokens(self) -> int:
@@ -115,14 +116,21 @@ class ChatAgent:
             return
         self.messages.insert(0, SystemChatMessage(content=self.system_prompt))
 
+    def _sync_pending_from_orphan_user(self) -> None:
+        """If history ends with a user message, that turn is incomplete → retryable."""
+        if self.messages and isinstance(self.messages[-1], UserChatMessage):
+            self.pending_retry_text = self.messages[-1].content
+        else:
+            self.pending_retry_text = None
+
     async def load_history(self) -> None:
         """Replace in-memory messages from the bound memory session."""
         if self.memory is None or self.session_id is None:
             msg = "load_history requires memory and session_id"
             raise RuntimeError(msg)
         self.messages = await self.memory.list_messages(self.session_id)
-        self.pending_retry_text = None
         self._ensure_system_prompt()
+        self._sync_pending_from_orphan_user()
 
     async def bind_session(self, session_id: int, *, load: bool = True) -> None:
         """Attach a memory session id; optionally load existing messages."""
@@ -137,16 +145,31 @@ class ChatAgent:
         if self.memory is not None and self.session_id is not None:
             _ = await self.memory.append_message(self.session_id, message)
 
-    def _rollback_turn(self, pre_len: int, user_text: str) -> None:
+    def _user_index(self, user_msg: UserChatMessage) -> int:
-        del self.messages[pre_len:]
+        for i in range(len(self.messages) - 1, -1, -1):
+            if self.messages[i] is user_msg:
+                return i
+        # Fallback: last matching content user message
+        for i in range(len(self.messages) - 1, -1, -1):
+            msg = self.messages[i]
+            if isinstance(msg, UserChatMessage) and msg.content == user_msg.content:
+                return i
+        msg = "user message not found in history"
+        raise RuntimeError(msg)
+
+    def _rollback_partial(self, user_index: int, user_text: str) -> None:
+        """Drop assistant/tool messages after the user; keep user for retry/DB."""
+        del self.messages[user_index + 1 :]
         self.pending_retry_text = user_text
 
     async def _run_from_user_message(self, user_msg: UserChatMessage) -> AsyncIterator[AgentEvent]:
-        """Run the tool loop for an already-appended user message; persist only on success."""
+        """Run the tool loop for an already-appended user message.
-        pre_len = len(self.messages) - 1
+
-        if pre_len < 0 or self.messages[pre_len] is not user_msg:
+        On success, persists assistant/tool messages produced after the user.
-            pre_len = len(self.messages)
+        On failure, keeps the user message (already in memory/DB) and sets
-            self.messages.append(user_msg)
+        ``pending_retry_text`` so ``retry()`` can re-run without duplicating it.
+        """
+        user_index = self._user_index(user_msg)
 
         completed = False
         turn_usage = TokenUsage()
@@ -176,32 +199,53 @@ class ChatAgent:
             completed = True
         except BaseException:
             if not completed:
-                self._rollback_turn(pre_len, user_msg.content)
+                self._rollback_partial(user_index, user_msg.content)
             raise
 
         self.last_turn_usage = turn_usage
         self.last_request_usage = last_request
         self.last_turn_rounds = turn_rounds
-        for message in self.messages[pre_len:]:
+        for message in self.messages[user_index + 1 :]:
             await self._persist(message)
         self.pending_retry_text = None
 
     async def run(self, user_text: str) -> AsyncIterator[AgentEvent]:
-        """Append a user message, run the tool loop, yield events, persist only on success."""
+        """Append a user message (persist immediately), run the tool loop, yield events."""
         self._ensure_system_prompt()
         user_msg = UserChatMessage(content=user_text)
         self.messages.append(user_msg)
+        await self._persist(user_msg)
         async for event in self._run_from_user_message(user_msg):
             yield event
 
     async def retry(self) -> AsyncIterator[AgentEvent]:
-        """Re-run the last failed user turn (no duplicate user message in history/DB)."""
+        """Re-run the incomplete last user turn without appending a new user message.
+
+        Useful after a failed/cancelled turn (user already in memory/DB) or after
+        ``load_history`` when the session ends with an orphan user message.
+        """
+        text = self.pending_retry_text
+        if text is None:
+            self._sync_pending_from_orphan_user()
             text = self.pending_retry_text
         if text is None:
             msg = "nothing to retry"
             raise RuntimeError(msg)
+
         self._ensure_system_prompt()
+        if self.messages and isinstance(self.messages[-1], UserChatMessage):
+            user_msg = self.messages[-1]
+            if user_msg.content != text:
+                # Pending text out of sync: replace trailing user
+                user_msg = UserChatMessage(content=text)
+                self.messages[-1] = user_msg
+        else:
             user_msg = UserChatMessage(content=text)
             self.messages.append(user_msg)
+            # Already persisted on the original run when memory is bound; only
+            # persist if this is a reconstructed orphan without DB (no memory).
+            if self.memory is None or self.session_id is None:
+                await self._persist(user_msg)
+
         async for event in self._run_from_user_message(user_msg):
             yield event

src/plyngent/cli/repl.py

@@ -36,12 +36,12 @@ Commands:
   /model [id]        Show or switch model
   /tools [on|off]    Show or toggle tools
   /rounds [n]        Show or set max tool-loop rounds
-  /retry             Retry the last failed user turn (after errors)
+  /retry             Re-run incomplete last user turn (DB/orphan user; no retype)
   /status            Show session/provider/tools/rounds status
 
-On network/API errors or Ctrl+C during a turn, the turn is not saved to
+User messages are saved immediately. On API errors or Ctrl+C, partial
-the DB. Auto-retry waits 10s, 20s, then 30s (Ctrl+C cancels waits or the
+assistant/tool output is discarded but the user message stays (so /retry
-in-flight turn; use /retry later). Streaming is on by default.
+works after resume, not only via readline history). Auto-retry: 10s/20s/30s.
 
 Tab completes slash commands and some arguments (provider, model, tools).
 Use --session ID or /resume to continue a prior chat after restart.

src/plyngent/cli/retry.py

@@ -139,22 +139,24 @@ async def run_turn_with_retries(
 ) -> bool:
     """Run a chat turn with automatic retries on failure.
 
-    ``starter`` produces the event stream for the current attempt (``agent.run``
+    ``starter`` produces the event stream for the first attempt (usually
-    or ``agent.retry``). Returns True if the turn completed successfully.
+    ``agent.run``). After a failure that sets ``pending_retry_text``, further
+    attempts use ``agent.retry`` so the user message is not duplicated in
+    history/DB (it is already persisted).
 
-    Ctrl+C during a model/tool turn cancels the in-flight task (level-1 cancel).
+    Ctrl+C cancels the in-flight task; user message stays in DB for ``/retry``.
-    The agent rolls back the turn and keeps ``pending_retry_text`` for ``/retry``.
     """
     max_retries = len(delays)
     attempt = 0
+    current: Callable[[], AsyncIterator[AgentEvent]] = starter
     while True:
         try:
-            await run_cancellable(render_events(starter()))
+            await run_cancellable(render_events(current()))
         except asyncio.CancelledError:
             # Do not auto-retry cancelled turns — user intent was stop, not retry.
             click.echo()
             click.secho(
-                "cancelled (turn not saved); use /retry to try again",
+                "cancelled; user message kept — use /retry to try again",
                 fg="yellow",
             )
             click.echo()
@@ -166,6 +168,8 @@ async def run_turn_with_retries(
             return False
         except Exception as exc:  # noqa: BLE001 — surface and optionally retry
             click.secho(f"error: {exc}", fg="red")
+            if agent.pending_retry_text is not None:
+                current = agent.retry
             if attempt >= max_retries:
                 if agent.pending_retry_text is not None:
                     click.secho(

tests/test_agent/test_loop.py

@@ -505,7 +505,7 @@ async def test_chat_agent_memory_roundtrip() -> None:
     await store.close()
 
 
-async def test_chat_agent_failed_turn_not_persisted() -> None:
+async def test_chat_agent_failed_turn_keeps_user_in_db() -> None:
     store = await MemoryStore.open(DatabaseConfig())
     session = await store.create_session(name="t")
 
@@ -531,10 +531,13 @@ async def test_chat_agent_failed_turn_not_persisted() -> None:
     with pytest.raises(RuntimeError, match="network down"):
         _ = [e async for e in agent.run("hello")]
 
-    assert agent.messages == []
+    assert len(agent.messages) == 1
+    assert isinstance(agent.messages[0], UserChatMessage)
     assert agent.pending_retry_text == "hello"
     loaded = await store.list_messages(session.sid)
-    assert loaded == []
+    assert len(loaded) == 1
+    assert isinstance(loaded[0], UserChatMessage)
+    assert loaded[0].content == "hello"
     await store.close()
 
 
@@ -581,7 +584,8 @@ async def test_chat_agent_retry_after_failure() -> None:
     with pytest.raises(RuntimeError, match="temporary"):
         _ = [e async for e in agent.run("ping")]
     assert agent.pending_retry_text == "ping"
-    assert await store.list_messages(session.sid) == []
+    # User already in DB after first attempt
+    assert len(await store.list_messages(session.sid)) == 1
 
     events = [e async for e in agent.retry()]
     assert any(isinstance(e, TextDeltaEvent) and e.content == "recovered" for e in events)
@@ -590,9 +594,30 @@ async def test_chat_agent_retry_after_failure() -> None:
     assert len(loaded) == 2
     assert isinstance(loaded[0], UserChatMessage)
     assert loaded[0].content == "ping"
+    # Single user message (no duplicate on retry)
+    assert sum(1 for m in loaded if isinstance(m, UserChatMessage)) == 1
     await store.close()
 
 
+async def test_retry_after_resume_orphan_user() -> None:
+    store = await MemoryStore.open(DatabaseConfig())
+    session = await store.create_session(name="t")
+    _ = await store.append_message(session.sid, UserChatMessage(content="left hanging"))
+
+    client = ScriptedClient([_response(AssistantChatMessage(content="ok now"))])
+    agent = ChatAgent(client, model="m", memory=store, session_id=session.sid)
+    await agent.load_history()
+    assert agent.pending_retry_text == "left hanging"
+
+    events = [e async for e in agent.retry()]
+    assert any(isinstance(e, TextDeltaEvent) and e.content == "ok now" for e in events)
+    loaded = await store.list_messages(session.sid)
+    assert len(loaded) == 2
+    assert sum(1 for m in loaded if isinstance(m, UserChatMessage)) == 1
+    await store.close()
+
+
+
 async def test_chat_agent_system_prompt_prepended() -> None:
     from plyngent.lmproto.openai_compatible.model import SystemChatMessage
 

tests/test_cli/test_retry.py

@@ -173,8 +173,11 @@ async def test_cancel_turn_rolls_back_and_sets_pending() -> None:
         await turn
 
     assert agent.pending_retry_text == "cancel-me"
-    assert agent.messages == []
+    assert len(agent.messages) == 1
-    assert await store.list_messages(session.sid) == []
+    assert isinstance(agent.messages[0], UserChatMessage)
+    loaded = await store.list_messages(session.sid)
+    assert len(loaded) == 1
+    assert isinstance(loaded[0], UserChatMessage)
     await store.close()
 
 
@@ -195,17 +198,16 @@ async def test_manual_retry_after_exhausted(monkeypatch: pytest.MonkeyPatch) ->
     )
     assert ok is False
     assert agent.pending_retry_text == "hold-me"
-    assert await store.list_messages(session.sid) == []
+    assert len(await store.list_messages(session.sid)) == 1
 
-    # Now succeed on manual /retry path
+    # Now succeed on manual /retry path (no second user message)
     client.fail_times = client.calls  # next call succeeds
     ok2 = await retry_pending_with_retries(agent)
-    # retry_pending uses default delays; force zero-wait already patched
-    # But fail_times set so first attempt of manual retry succeeds immediately
     assert ok2 is True
     assert agent.pending_retry_text is None
     loaded = await store.list_messages(session.sid)
     assert len(loaded) == 2
     assert isinstance(loaded[0], UserChatMessage)
     assert loaded[0].content == "hold-me"
+    assert sum(1 for m in loaded if isinstance(m, UserChatMessage)) == 1
     await store.close()